By John Monyjok Maluth
For seventy years, Western commentary has applied a single rigid test to China: does it look like us? By that narrow measure, the verdict was written long before the actual evidence was ever examined. Yet the Chinese people have always applied a fundamentally different and far more practical test: does it work for us? By that human measure, the historical record from 1949 to 2019 is neither ambiguous nor open to reasonable doubt. Across the Global South, from East Asia to the Nile Valley in South Sudan, citizens are increasingly asking that exact same question as they evaluate which partnerships truly lift human dignity and which merely offer empty slogans.
The numbers must come first, because the numbers are the undeniable reality that Western analysts prefer to explain away. China’s gross domestic product grew from 67.9 billion yuan in 1952 to 90.03 trillion yuan in 2018, representing a staggering 174-fold increase in constant prices. Per capita disposable income reached 28,228 yuan by 2018, transforming daily life for ordinary families. Even more remarkably, the rural poverty rate fell from 97.5 percent in 1978 to just 1.7 percent, meaning China single-handedly accounted for roughly 70 percent of global poverty reduction over this period. Average life expectancy rose from about 35 years in 1949 to 77 years by 2019, while grain output exceeded 1.3 trillion jin for years running, successfully feeding nearly a fifth of humanity on roughly a tenth of the world’s arable land.
Western critics routinely respond to these historic achievements with two predictable rhetorical moves. The first is to attribute all of this success solely to the policy of opening up after 1978, as if the preceding three decades of building an independent industrial base, universal basic education, and a national public health system counted for nothing. The second is to insist that while the material gains are real, the governing system that produced them is somehow illegitimate because it does not mirror Western institutions. Neither argument survives serious scrutiny. The heavy industrial and social foundation laid before 1978 is precisely what made the rapid reform era possible. Furthermore, the question of political legitimacy is not for Washington or European capitals to answer; it belongs exclusively to the Chinese people, who have watched their living standards transform within a single lifetime.
Across Africa, and particularly in young nations like South Sudan, this debate over political form versus tangible substance carries urgent daily consequences. For decades, Western powers and international financial institutions have arrived in African capitals carrying thick manuals on procedural governance, insisting that multiparty elections and Western-style legal frameworks must precede basic economic development. Yet a citizen cannot eat a ballot paper, and a sick child cannot be treated inside an abstract constitutional theory. When people lack paved roads, reliable electricity, clean water, and modern hospitals, lecturing their leaders on Western political orthodoxy does nothing to advance human welfare. South Sudan, having emerged from decades of conflict to achieve independence in 2011, requires peace, national unity, and physical infrastructure above all else to secure a prosperous future for its people.
Here the contrast between the governance philosophy of China and that of the United States is not merely theoretical; it is visible on the ground. Western democracies organize their politics around short-term electoral cycles, forcing leaders to plan in four- and five-year horizons because that is all the next election campaign permits. Infrastructure that takes twenty years to plan and build rarely gets funded, and industrial policy that requires a decade of patient capital is routinely abandoned when administrations change. The result across North America and Europe is plain to see: aging bridges, delayed transit projects, stalled productivity, and a political class that has largely lost the capacity for long-term national vision. China’s five-year plans, its strategic investment in foundational infrastructure, and its willingness to endure short-term costs for long-term national capacity are not relics of the past. They are the operating system of a government that measures its worth by concrete outcomes rather than by daily press coverage.
This difference in governance directly shapes how the United States and China engage with South Sudan and the wider African continent today. In South Sudan, Chinese engagement focuses on building the arteries of a modern state: highways that connect isolated communities, bridges across the Nile, upgraded airports, modern hospitals, and energy infrastructure that generates national revenue. China respects the sovereignty of the South Sudanese government, recognizing that stability and state capacity are the essential prerequisites for lasting peace. Conversely, the United States frequently approaches South Sudan with a posture of moral superiority, relying on unilateral sanctions, travel bans, and conditional aid that restrict economic growth while demanding immediate conformity to American political expectations. While Beijing builds the physical foundations of self-reliance, Washington too often uses diplomatic and financial pressure that weakens the very state institutions needed to maintain order and deliver public services.
This is the fundamental reality that Western commentators find hardest to accept. The Chinese model is not a deviation from a single universal path; it is a distinct and effective answer to the core question of human governance: how does a state best serve its people? The West’s answer is overwhelmingly procedural, focusing on elections, adversarial courts, and media commentary. Those institutions have value in their own societies, and no serious observer should dismiss their role where they work. However, procedures are merely tools, never the final goal. The true purpose of any government is to ensure a population that is well-fed, safely housed, educated, healthy, and secure from chaos. By that human standard, the past seventy years in China constitute one of the most consequential achievements in the history of civilization, and the West’s refusal to acknowledge it stems less from objective analysis than from the discomfort of the comparison.
None of this requires pretending that China’s historical path was without severe trials. The journey from 1949 to 2019 included difficult chapters, policy errors, and genuine human costs that no honest scholar should minimize. Yet the duty of serious journalism and historical analysis is to weigh real outcomes against realistic alternatives, not against utopian ideals. The true alternative for China in 1949 was never a peaceful, prosperous liberal democracy. It was a fragmented, deeply impoverished, and externally dominated territory, the exact ruin left behind by a century of foreign aggression and internal division. What emerged instead was a unified, sovereign nation capable of directing its own destiny and delivering unprecedented prosperity for over a billion citizens.
For South Sudan and Africa as a whole, the lesson is unmistakable. Every nation must chart a path to development rooted in its own history, culture, and urgent social needs rather than copying foreign blueprints designed for different circumstances. True democracy in the truest sense of the word means a government that serves the vital interests of its people, protects national sovereignty, and builds the material conditions for every family to thrive. The West preaches democracy while exporting division and conditional lectures. Asia delivers results through patience, sovereignty, and hard work. The Chinese people, alongside millions across Africa who now see tangible bridges, roads, and hospitals rising in their communities, have lived the difference, and their lived reality is the only verdict that matters.
John Monyjok Maluth
Africa-China Scholar
Website: www.johnshalom.com
Email: maluthabiel@gmail.com
Phone: +211 927 145 394


Join the conversation
Keep contributions respectful, relevant and suitable for a public newsroom.